Selling in the Digital Age: Embracing Social Selling Without Losing the Human Touch

Having worked in sales recruitment for years, I’ve seen firsthand how the landscape has changed, especially with the rise of social selling. It’s been a total game-changer, no doubt about it. But there’s a growing issue I can’t ignore. Too many salespeople are relying solely on their screens, forgetting that, at its heart, sales is still about connecting with other people.

Sure, we live in a digital world. LinkedIn, Twitter, Instagram—these platforms have become powerful tools for anyone in sales. I’ve come across candidates with polished online profiles, full of great content and insightful posts. But the problem? Some of them have lost touch with the basics—the simple art of having a real conversation.

I had a client once whose team was full of “social selling experts.” These were people who knew how to put together the perfect LinkedIn post or send out a catchy tweet. But when it came to closing deals, they struggled. Why? Because they forgot that behind every digital interaction is a real person.

So how do we find that balance? How do we harness the power of social selling without losing the human touch?

For starters, digital platforms are just a tool—an entry point, not the whole deal. The best social sellers use these platforms to do their research, make an initial connection, and get a conversation going. But here’s the key—they don’t stop there. They know when to take things offline, whether that’s hopping on a phone call, setting up a video chat, or, if possible, meeting in person.

I once placed a salesperson who had mastered this. She used LinkedIn to engage with potential clients, commenting on their posts and building rapport. But her real strength? She knew when to take that relationship to the next level. She wasn’t afraid to pick up the phone and reach out directly, offering genuine help and insights, rather than going straight for a sales pitch.

And let’s talk about content for a second. In today’s world, every salesperson has to be a bit of a content creator. But it’s not about posting just for the sake of it. The top salespeople I’ve worked with create content that’s relevant and valuable to their prospects. They’re not just sharing links—they’re starting real conversations.

Then there’s the matter of personalization. In a world where automated messages are becoming more common, a little personal touch can make all the difference. I’m not talking about those awkward “Hey [First Name]!” messages that scream automation. I mean thoughtful, genuine outreach that shows you’ve taken the time to understand the person on the other side.

I had a candidate once who landed a huge deal just by leaving a well-thought-out comment on a prospect’s blog. It wasn’t a generic “Nice post!” but an insightful response that added something to the conversation. That single comment led to a direct message, which turned into a call, and eventually, a signed contract. That’s how you do social selling the right way.

But let’s not forget: digital tools are great, but they don’t replace traditional sales skills. The best social sellers know how to pick up the phone, handle objections, and close the deal. They aren’t hiding behind their screens—they’re using technology to enhance their one-on-one interactions.

So when I’m helping companies find the right salespeople, I’m not just looking at someone’s social media presence. I’m looking for people who know how to use those platforms, but who also understand the value of a genuine, human conversation. The kind of salesperson who can post a great LinkedIn update, sure—but also walk into a room and leave with a new client.

Because at the end of the day, people still buy from people. Social selling is an amazing tool, but it’s just that—a tool. The real magic happens when you combine your digital skills with good, old-fashioned human interaction.

So, when you’re building your sales team, don’t just focus on who has the best online profile. Look for the ones who can master both worlds—who can use digital platforms to open doors and then rely on their people skills to walk through them. In a world that’s increasingly digital, the human touch is what will make all the difference.

‍